Joey Fatone is one of the five original members of *NSYNC Fatone, who is currently in Broadway's &Juliet, tells PEOPLE what he thinks it will take to make a reunion of the beloved boy band happen ...

Inside, Fatone and the Saved by the 90's members made it all worthwhile, added Busch, who went out during the show with Police Chief Arthur Flaherty Sr. to assess the damage and assist residents.